The poet is talking to the urn again. No real passion is going on; the scenes on the urn are frozen. But they may look sweet and attractive. Line When old age shall this generation waste,.
When people who live now will grow old and die, Line Thou shalt remain, in midst of other woe. That is not ours. There is a problem here. There are two editions without quotation marks. But I must say that quotation marks around the whole last lines seem more logical.
So more likely this is said by the urn. Not much, in my case. Hope you enjoyed reading this! Like Like. I read your explanation. I love it. It means everything that is created by God is beautiful, because, he is beautiful. Thanks for your comment. Although this is not in the poem itself! Thank you very much. Finally I found perfect explanation that I needed. I wish you were my professor. Like Liked by 1 person. You know, Keats is a Romantic Poet and the primary aim of most of the romantic poets have always been to draw the focus of people towards nature instead of modernization occurring during that era.
The truth and all the secrets of life and world lie in the nature itself. Yes, I believe he is talking about an intuitive, simple grasp of the world around us, which is a Romantic idea. I agree with you. Your analysis is a perfect piece of art. It is like a window through which we see, hear and feel the exact touch of the thoughts, imagination and passion of the poem and its characters.
Thanks for giving us the purpose why we should read literature. Thank you so much for this, this really helps a lot. But, could you please talk about other Keats poems too?
Pastoral is a positive word with positive connotations such as friendliness. So cold seems to clash with that. Hope this answers your comment. Thank you, your efforts are facilitated. You have awakened the sleeping feeling in the urn as well as in my sleeping emotion.
Concerning the expression truth is beauty… its odd her in this context, because it is abstract one that it does not belong to the poem theme or interpretation but, we as readers should find explanation that harmonize the poem context- as we are settling down the ambiguity and the paradoxical occurrences on the urn scenic we have the continuation of the abstract two facts that the urn in fact expresses the truth of the entity of the physical object while the beautiful scenes are only in our imagination the are beautiful.
The combination of the true urn and the imaginable beauty are a completion one with the another. Not that the poem draws any clear conclusions; it rather draws your attention to these issues. Also it asks what the function is of art? Is it to represent nature, or some idea or truth, or beauty?
And why not all at once? This is explained so beautifully. Thank you for helping us understand this poem better! It will definitely help write my Literature paper tomorrow!
Art refer to the nature of human being which is itself closely related to beauty. All the human love beauty, this is the very much truth of life. So if a human being loves beauty than he must love art which is the way to make the beauty eternal to explain it to the world as a great truth of life…. Just like art, unless well preserved, is always with us. So as generations passed, it stays to tell the present generation what the previous one was like.
Thanks for your comment! About the equation of truth and beauty, this is an older idea that was proposed by Plato. So I guess he leaves it up to the reader to develop her own explanations. Thanks for the explanation of a very confusing poem. But I am not very clear about the the term ATTIC because its different in the dictionary so could you help me in that.
Yeah, it means Greek. Attica is the region around Athens and Attic is the adjective of that. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account. You are commenting using your Twitter account. You are commenting using your Facebook account. Notify me of new comments via email. Notify me of new posts via email.
Bored Physician After he finished school, Keats studied as a surgeon. Enough said. What men or gods are these? What mad pursuit? What pipes and timbrels? What little town by river or sea-shore, 35 Or mountain-built with peaceful citadel, Is emptied of its folk, this pious morn? Pipes are flutes. A timbrel is an ancient tambourine. Stanza 2: Line Heard melodies are sweet, but those unheard Line Are sweeter; therefore, ye soft pipes, play on; This stanza speaks of things that are not in the scene on the urn.
Line Pipe to the spirit ditties of no tone: A ditty is a simple song. Line Fair youth, beneath the trees, thou canst not leave Line Thy song, nor ever can those trees be bare; These lines and the ones until the end of the stanza teach us another aspect of art.
Line Bold Lover, never, never canst thou kiss, The lover will never get the kiss he is waiting for. Line Though winning near the goal—yet, do not grieve; But the lover still has won a few points. His love will be forever, and she will forever be beautiful. Stanza 3: Line Ah, happy happy boughs! He views the urn as a world where things never change and can never be destroyed, which is pretty much the definition of eternity.
Except, of course, if the urn breaks. Finally, he calls the scenes depicted on the urn a "Cold Pastoral. But "cold"? Are these lines supposed to be a put-down, or are they actually a form of praise.
They sound more like a put-down — like the speaker changed his mind after all his talk about happiness and warm bodies. He might be accusing the urn of being distant and uncaring. You might compare the feeling to looking at remote stars and planets, which seem cold and indifferent but also provide a sense of beauty and comfort.
Overall, it seems he understands the urn even less at the end of the poem than at the beginning. The speaker imagines that after everyone in his generation is dead, the urn will still be around.
The problems or "woe" of the present generation will have been replaced by new problems. In fact, it has always given the same advice to everyone, throughout history, which is. Okay, get ready, because the next two lines are some of the most immortal ever written. Lines 'Beauty is truth, truth beauty'--that is all Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.
Beauty and truth are the same thing. Wait, no. That makes no sense at all. If beauty and truth are the same thing, then why do we have two different words for them? One of the sneakiest things about these lines is how they sound so darned confident, as if "Beauty is truth, truth beauty" were on a par with "Gravity makes things fall down.
Second, if you think we already knew that, why are you telling us? But we can try to say a bit about what these lines could mean. Manda Nauck Professional. What does Unravish D mean? He calls her the " unravish'd bride of quietness," which, if taken literally, would mean that the urn is married to a guy named Quietness. But wait — urns can 't get married, so he probably just means a really old pot and quietness go hand in hand.
Predrag Freixieira Professional. What is on the urn? The urn is a historian of rural scenes, which it depicts better than does the poetry of the speaker's era or perhaps language more generally. The speaker wonders what stories are being told by the images on the urn ; whether the figures it depicts are human beings or gods, and which part of Greece they are in. Alea Calbet Professional. What does Ode on a Grecian Urn mean? Ebtisam Feito Explainer.
What Leaf fringed legend haunts about the shape? A legend is a story. A fringe is a decorative border or an outer edge of something. The expression " leaf - fringed " refers to a decorative border or an outer edge of leaves. The word " haunts " can mean to remain consistently like a painting on an ancient Grecian urn.
Aksel Zherbin Explainer. Why do you think the speaker describes the urn as a historian in Ode on a Grecian Urn? He believes that the urn can tell stories from the depicted figure on the side of the urn.
0コメント